‘Shia’ Scholars Don't Have a History. They Have a Story. || FIRAQ SERIES #AMAR

80,385 views·Apr 17, 2026

Sign up to AMAR Academy for the full series: https://www.rahmaniyyah.com/firaq Sunni scholars built a rigorous science of history, isnad, narrator scrutiny, chains of transmission. Shia historiography didn't. It inherited polemics and folk memory, then called it history. In this video, Ustadh AbdulRahman Hassan exposes how these narratives were built, why they collapse under classical standards, and how To navigate through them.. The case study: Abdullah ibn Saba; the figure Shia scholars insist was a myth, despite appearing in their own earliest sources. Timestamps: 00:00:00 Introduction 00:36 Precap 01:30 The Biggest Lie The Shia Bring: The Companions Had Animosity Towards Each Other 02:36 How Do We Read History 03:10 Every Narration Needs Verification 03:21 You Should Never Trust These Books 04:03 Everything Has To Go Back To A Foundation Otherwise Face Detrimental Consequences 05:01 Stay Far From These Books If You Wish To Read History 07:13 The Books You Should Actually Read To Learn History 08:12 When You Can't Check Chains Yourself; Read Ibn Kathir 09:03 Do Not Simply Take Everything You Read 10:31 Abu Mikhnaf: Run Far If You Come Across That Name 11:46 What Means Did The Pseudo-historians Take To Distort History 14:02 Mohamed Bin Sirin And The Birth Of Isnad 14:36 The Qur'anic Principle: Verify Before You Believe Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/abdulrahmanhassanofficial25 Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/cw/AMARofficial Telegram: https://t.me/+c87I9vy6kqkxOWZk YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@rahmaniyyahofficial WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbBlpi2CHDyjG4ZI1I0g X (Formerly Twitter): https://x.com/UstAbdulrahman #abdulrahmanhassan #AlMadrasatuArRahmaniyyah #AMAR