9.9K subscribers
96 views·
جواب على شبهةAn Answer to a suspicious matter جواب شبهة لا بد أن يأتي دليل لكل عبادة بأن صرفها لغير الله شرك وإلا فليس ذلك بشرك The answer to the misconception that there must be a daleel (evidence from the Quran and Sunnah) for every distinct act of worship to be (considered) shirk (associating partners with Allah) if it is devoted to a diety other than Allah. _____________________________________________ شف لو طلب أحد مثل بعض الناس Now see if someone asked for, say like how some people (do), الذين يطلبون دليل خاص على أن الذبح عبادة, daleel (textual evidence from the Quran and Sunnah) that sacrificial slaughtering is an act of worship, وأن من ذبح لغير الله أشرك, And that whosoever sacrifices to other than Allah has committed shirk (associating partners with Allah) … طيب لو طلبنا لكل عبادة دليل خاص If we want a specific daleel for every single act of worship, بأن من فعل لغير الله فقد أشرك That whosoever acts and dedicates to other than Allah has committed Shirk, إذا ما فائدة الأدلة العامة؟! Then what is the use of the general daleels? إذا لا يستفاد منها شيء, Accordingly, they are of no use. ما الفائدة من قوله جل وعلا: {واعبدوا الله ولا تشركوا به شيئا }, What is the use of His Exaltedness' (Allah's) statement:{and serve Allah and do not associate anything with Him}? إذا نريد دليلا لكل عبادة بعينها Then, we need a daleel for every specific act of worship أن من صرف لغير الله فقد أشرك, that whosoever devotes (an act of worship) to other than Allah has committed shirk. طيب معنى هذا أن الأدلة العامة لا فائدة منها, This means that the general daleels are useless. طيب ما الأدلة العامة؟ So, what are the general daleels? "اعبدوا الله", بما يُعبد الله؟ بالعبادات, عموم العبادات, "Worship Allah", how is Allah worshipped? By acts of worship. "ولا تشركوا به شيئا", لا تشركوا به بماذا؟ بعموم العبادات, "And do not associate anything with him" what are to be dedicated to him alone? Acts of worship. إذا طلبنا أو طلب منا أو طلب أحد: If we ask or are asked by someone, أعطني دليل خاص أن مثلا الذبح لغير الله شرك, Give me a daleel that specifically states that sacrificial slaughtering to other than Allah is Shirk, والنذر لغير الله شرك, والسجود لغير الله شرك, making vows to other than Allah is Shirk, prostrating to other than Allah is Shirk, والتوكل على غير الله شرك, And relying on other than Allah is Shirk, إذا هذه الأدلة العامة لا فائدة منها! Then these general daleels are useless! ولا معنى لها! وهذا من أبطل الباطل, And they have no meaning! And this is the gravest of falsehood. ربنا جل وعلا أمر أمرا عاما قال: "اعبدوا الله", Our Lord the Exalted commanded us saying: "Worship Allah" ونهى نهي عام فقال: "ولا تشركوا به شيئا", And forbade with a general prohibition saying: "and do not associate anything with Him." ويُعمل بالعموم على عمومه And what is general is to be acted upon in general terms ما لم يأتي مخصص خاص unless something specifies it. بعد ما أمرنا أن نعبد الله وحده لا شريك له مخلصا له الدين في كل العبادات, After He (Allah) commanded us to worship Him alone without associating any partners with Him and to devote our religion and all acts of worship to Him alone, ليس بالضرورة أن يأتينا دليل عن كل عبادة بعينها It is not necessary to have a daleel for every single act of worship; اسجد وانذر وتوكل واذبح, لا لا, prostrate, vow, rely, and slaughter sacrificially, no. هذه عبادة أو ليست عبادة؟ الذبح الأضحية عبادة أو ليست عبادة؟ عبادة, Is this worship or not? Slaughtering sacrificially, isn’t it an act of worship? It is. لو أن شخصا ما يضحي لغير الله If someone dedicates their sacrifice to someone other than Allah, يعني يتعبد هذا المضحى له هذا شرك لأنه عبد غير الله بهذه العبادة, meaning a form of worship to this other being, this is Shirk because he worshipped other than Allah by doing that. والأدلة العامة يعمل بها, نعم And the general daleels are acted upon, yes.
